California Supreme Court Adopts Broad New Misclassification Test

The California Supreme Court has adopted a new legal standard that will make it much more difficult for businesses to classify workers as independent contractors. Specifically, the court adopted a new standard for determining whether a company “employs” or is the “employer” for purposes of the California Wage Orders.

Under the new “ABC” test, a worker is considered an employee under the Wage Orders unless the hiring entity establishes all three of these prongs:

  1. A) the worker is free from the control and direction of the hirer in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of such work and in fact;
  2. B) the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and
  3. C) the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed for the hiring entity.

This decision not only expands the definition of “employee” under the California Wage Orders, it also imposes an affirmative burden on companies to prove that independent contractors are being properly classified.

From an industry standpoint, this decision is a seismic shift for California wage and hour law. The nonunion sector will have a much more difficult time classifying employees as independent contractors. The court now imposes a burden on businesses to defend their classification of workers as independent contractors. Misclassification of such workers will result in significant legal exposure with respect to wage and hour compliance.

Immigration Worker Protection Act

We are reminding contractors that in 2017 California passed a new law, the Immigration Worker Protection Act that prohibits employers from voluntarily cooperating with ICE.  In brief, under the new law, employers are prohibited from allowing immigration enforcement agents into non-public areas of the workplace without a judicial warrant and from allowing ICE agents to access, review or obtain employee records without a subpoena or judicial warrant. (There is an exception to this requirement for Notices of Inspection, which are generally letter requests for Form I-9s and sent to an employer at least 3 days in advance of the inspection).   The new law also requires employers to provide their employees with certain written notices when the employer is notified that it will be inspected by ICE. (The Labor Commissioner is required to develop a template notice before July 1, 2018, which it will likely make available on its website).  Employers who violate the new law will be subject to penalties ranging from $2,000 to $5,000 for first violations, and $5,000 to $10,000 for subsequent violations.

It’s recommended that contractors educate their managers and any employees likely to encounter an ICE agent (such as receptionists, security officers, jobsite foremen, etc.) not to provide access to ICE agents unless they produce a judicial warrant, and not to voluntarily provide them with any employee records.  Field employees should be advised to contact a foreman or management if approached by ICE, and to take a picture of any “official-looking” paperwork presented by ICE to send to a manager (if the manager is not present) or to your main office for review.  Managers/foremen should also be instructed to contact upper management if approached by ICE, and to provide upper management with any “official-looking” documents presented by ICE.  ICE agents should be politely told to wait in a public area (which may be outside or on the street, in some cases) until they have contacted upper management.  ICE agents may act like they have the authority to demand access to employee records or non-public work areas without a warrant or subpoena, they do not—giving in to their demands when they do not have the proper documentation may subject the company to penalties.

If contractors are not doing so already, you should keep all Form I-9s in a separate file.  (You can put a copy of the employee’s Form I-9 in their personnel file as well).  You should also be using the most recent Form I-9 for new hires.  Following is a link to the current Form I-9 (released Jul. 17, 2017):

In early January, 2018, US Immigration and Customs Enforcement also updated its I-9 Handbook for Employers (available at which we suggest you print out for your office or jobsite use.

Conducting an I-9 audit, is also recommended.


Recent Posts

California’s Minimum Wage to Increase to $16.00 Per Hour on January 1, 2024

California law mandates that the minimum wage be increased in response to inflation. Specifically, California Labor Code section 1182.12 delegates authority to the Director of Finance to annually determine and certify to the Governor and State Legislature whether an adjustment…

October 2, 2023

Employers Are Not Liable For The Spread of Covid to Employees’ Household Members

The California Supreme Court unanimously ruled that employers owe no duty to prevent “take home” cases of Covid-19 and are not liable to nonemployees who contract Covid from employee household members who bring the virus home from the workplace. The…

September 26, 2023

Brunch Break

Join us in an opportunity to get to know your fellow WPCCA members for brunch at the beautiful Old Ranch Country Club in Seal Beach! This event will feature a presentation by Molly Burns, Environmental Affairs Manager at Dunn-Edwards, who…

August 3, 2023

WPCCA 2023 Mid-Year Legislative Update

California State Legislature has crossed the midway point of the 2022 Legislative Session. Legislators had until June 2nd to move legislation out of their house of origin. Bills that did not clear that hurdle must be shelved for the year….

July 25, 2023

WPCCA Construction Contracts 101 Webinar Series: Private Works Remedies

This 2 part webinar series on Construction Contracts will provide an overview on construction contracts and means to mitigate risks for contractors and subcontractors engaging in public and private works. Join our part 2 webinar on Private Works Remedies presented…

July 11, 2023