Pay-When-Paid Clauses Unenforceable

In the recent case of Crosno Construction Inc. v. Travelers Casualty, the Fourth District California Court of Appeals decided that an industry standard “pay-when-paid” contract clause (part of the AGC Short Form Subcontract) was ruled void and unenforceable. The ruling was based on the grounds that the pay-when-paid clause violated state public policy because it did not provide for payment to the subcontractor within a reasonable time since payment was delayed indefinitely for as long as it took the general contractor to pursue its claim against the project owner.

 

Practical Considerations:

 

  • Subcontractors of public works projects should review existing subcontracts to determine whether pay-when-paid provisions in their contract complies with the Crosno ruling.
  • If subcontractors on public works projects have been waiting for payment for an extended period of time due to nonpayment by the owner, recovery on a payment bond claim prior to the resolution of the dispute between the general contractor and the owner may be a feasible option. Sub-contractors in this situation may wish to first send a demand for payment to the general con-tractor citing the Crosno case.

 

Before taking action, it is recommended that public works subcontractors consult with their firm’s attorney to ask about their remedies under Crosno and what avenues to payment may be available to them.

 

As an LAPFCA member, you have access to our legal counsel. Please respond to this email if you’d like to utilize this option.

 

Click here to read the memo from legal on the case.

Click here to read the case itself.

Recent Posts

WPCCA ConstructConnect Live Demo

Join us for a live demo with ConstructConnect, the leading preconstruction platform that helps commercial construction professionals find more projects, bid smarter, and work faster. Date: Tuesday, November 18, 2025 Time: 11:00am – 12:00pm Location: via Zoom Key Takeaways: Access 750,000+ active…

October 8, 2025

WPCCA AI for Personal Productivity & Firm Transformation Workshop

In this fast-paced, hands-on workshop, AI consultant Stjepan Mikulic will help you turn AI into measurable results—both personally and across your entire firm. You’ll learn how to create custom GPTs, use AI to build presentations, visuals, and reports. Then, we’ll…

September 24, 2025

WPCCA Document Crunch Live Demo

Join us for a live demo of Document Crunch, the industry’s leading AI-powered risk platform built to simplify complex contracts and project documents, accelerate decision-making, and keep projects moving forward. Document Crunch empowers your team to quickly review contracts, specifications,…

September 10, 2025

WPCCA 3 Pillars of AI Implementation Webinar

Join us for an engaging presentation with Stjepan Mikulic, founder of AI in AEC, a global training provider serving architects, engineers, and construction professionals in more than 60 countries. Stjepan will explore the three key aspects every firm must navigate…

August 21, 2025

What Employers Need to Know About No Tax on Overtime

On July 3, 2025, the U.S. House of Representatives narrowly passed H.R.1, the so-called “One Big Beautiful Bill Act,” ending a dramatic journey through Congress that dominated headlines in recent weeks. The Act includes several provisions related to campaign promises…

July 23, 2025
MORE STORIES