SB 465 Follow Up – Does a Contractor’s History of Legal Settlements in CA Indicate Poor Workmanship?

Should every legal settlement, arbitration and judgement that your company has been involved in be publicly posted online by the Contractors State Licensing Board (CSLB)?  This is the public policy question being asked after the Berkeley balcony collapse tragedy in 2015.  It was later revealed that the contractor who built the apartment building in question had a prior history of being involved in multiple construction defect settlements.  The California Legislature has tasked the CSLB to determine if this information could be used to better protect consumers in the future if it were to be made publicly available online for every contractor in the state.   You may remember SB 465 from the 2016 legislative session.  That measure originally would have required reporting of all settlements, arbitrations and judgments to the CSLB.  The measure was amended to a study bill at our request.

The survey below is intended to help CSLB establish if this information is helpful in their consumer protection directive.  On your behalf, we have previously testified that this potential “metric” is not a good indicator of contractor competence or responsibility. Here’s why:

  • Everybody Gets Sued in Construction Defect Claims — Construction defect claims often include every contractor on a job regardless of their involvement in the disputed work.  Lawyers’ hunt for deep pockets – $$$ is a big reason; and
  • Insurance Companies Compel Settlements Regardless of a Contractor’s Innocence — Insurance companies often encourage settlement regardless of a contractor’s work being in question due to the excessive cost of litigation in California.  “Get out early, get out cheaper” is the mantra;
  • Settlements Do Not = “BAD CONTRACTOR” – Due to the litigious nature of lawyers in California, there is not necessarily a linkage between the number of legal actions a contractor has been involved in and the competence or responsibility of that contractor. It may mean nothing more than that contractor has performed a lot of work in California.

If you are concerned about the prospect of having to divulge all your company’s litigation history to the CSLB and this information being publicly posted online, please take a moment to respond to the CSLB questionnaire below.  All responses are anonymous.


Your voice is important to CSLB!

Today, we’re asking for your input on a significant issue.

We are in the process of putting together a report for the state Legislature under Senate Bill 465 (Hill). The report will look at whether CSLB’s consumer protection mission would benefit by requiring licensed contractors to report specific court judgments, arbitration awards, and settlements.

We’re asking that you please give us five minutes or so of your time to complete a survey which will be an important component of the report.

Your answers are completely anonymous. You will not receive any further contact from CSLB or any other party based upon your taking this survey.

Please take the survey that best applies to your situation:

I am a Licensed Contractor

I used to be a Licensed Contractor

I am a Consumer

I work for an Insurance Company


Recent Posts

California’s Minimum Wage to Increase to $16.00 Per Hour on January 1, 2024

California law mandates that the minimum wage be increased in response to inflation. Specifically, California Labor Code section 1182.12 delegates authority to the Director of Finance to annually determine and certify to the Governor and State Legislature whether an adjustment…

October 2, 2023

Employers Are Not Liable For The Spread of Covid to Employees’ Household Members

The California Supreme Court unanimously ruled that employers owe no duty to prevent “take home” cases of Covid-19 and are not liable to nonemployees who contract Covid from employee household members who bring the virus home from the workplace. The…

September 26, 2023

Brunch Break

Join us in an opportunity to get to know your fellow WPCCA members for brunch at the beautiful Old Ranch Country Club in Seal Beach! This event will feature a presentation by Molly Burns, Environmental Affairs Manager at Dunn-Edwards, who…

August 3, 2023

WPCCA 2023 Mid-Year Legislative Update

California State Legislature has crossed the midway point of the 2022 Legislative Session. Legislators had until June 2nd to move legislation out of their house of origin. Bills that did not clear that hurdle must be shelved for the year….

July 25, 2023

WPCCA Construction Contracts 101 Webinar Series: Private Works Remedies

This 2 part webinar series on Construction Contracts will provide an overview on construction contracts and means to mitigate risks for contractors and subcontractors engaging in public and private works. Join our part 2 webinar on Private Works Remedies presented…

July 11, 2023